
A South Korean court has overturned Miryang City’s refusal to allow a funeral hall at a long-term care hospital, ruling the city’s decision unlawful. The court found no evidence the facility would lower nearby home values and determined it qualified as an ancillary hospital service. On October 29, the First Administrative Division of the Changwon District Court issued its ruling in favor of the medical corporation, which had sued the mayor of Miryang to challenge the city’s decision. The court’s decision confirms that the funeral hall qualified as an ancillary facility of the hospital.
The corporation built the hospital in a Class 1 residential zone, which permits medical facilities but bars stand-alone funeral homes. The hospital, located in Miryang, South Gyeongsang Province, has one basement level and four aboveground floors, and has been operational since October 2023. The zoning designation protects neighborhoods primarily composed of low-rise housing and allows medical facilities, while barring stand-alone funeral facilities.
Hospital’s funeral hall meets legal criteria
The hospital, operational since October 2023, includes a 931.18-square-meter funeral hall in its basement. The corporation filed a business notification in December 2025, which Miryang rejected in January, citing zoning rules and a prior agreement with residents. The funeral hall’s size complies with the Medical Service Act, which stipulates that such facilities must not exceed one-fifth of the hospital’s total floor area. The hospital’s total floor area is 6,677.53 square meters, ensuring the funeral hall falls well within the legal limit. The court emphasized that the city misapplied zoning restrictions intended for stand-alone funeral facilities, which are not permitted in Class 1 residential zones.
The court ruled the funeral hall qualifies as an ancillary facility under the Medical Service Act, which allows hospitals to operate such halls for deceased patients. Additionally, the court noted that the Act on Funeral Services mandates operators to meet specific standards for facilities, equipment, and safety, and to file a notification with the local government. The corporation fulfilled these requirements, and Miryang did not contest the adequacy of the facility or the paperwork.
Read Also: Parkinson’s affects more than movement in Koreans
Residents’ objections lack legal weight
However, the court found this agreement non-binding, as neither the Act on Funeral Services nor the Medical Service Act mandates resident approval. In December 2021, after residents objected during construction, the corporation agreed with two village representatives that it would obtain residents’ consent before opening a funeral hall. Despite this, the court ruled that the agreement did not provide a legal basis for rejecting the filing, as statutory requirements take precedence over local accords.
The court also dismissed Miryang’s claims about traffic congestion and harm to the residential environment, noting the hall’s basement location and additional parking spaces. The court highlighted that the funeral hall has only three mourning rooms and that 40 additional parking spaces were secured, bringing the total to 62. The entrance and access roads are located behind the building, minimizing disruption to the neighborhood. The court deemed the city’s concerns about congestion and safety risks as speculative and unsupported by concrete analysis.
Ruling prioritizes hospital needs over local concerns
The decision highlights the court’s focus on legal compliance over local opposition. While residents submitted a petition against the hall, the corporation provided a statement of support signed by 94 people, including hospital staff. The court recognized the benefit to bereaved families of being able to hold funerals at the hospital where their relatives died. The court ruled that the alleged breach of good faith from the corporation’s failure to honor the agreement, and the possible infringement of residents’ right to pursue happiness, were insufficient to justify rejecting the filing.